Copper vs. Aluminum Gutters. Making the Right Choice for Your Home

aluminum gutter vs copper gutters

Gutters might not be the first thing that comes to mind when you think about your home, but they play a crucial role in protecting it from the elements. 

In the rainy climate of Seattle, gutters are more than a mere accessory – they are a necessity. When it comes to choosing the right gutter material for your Seattle home, the primary contenders are copper and aluminum. This article’s goal is to provide you with the information you need to make an informed decision regarding your home’s gutters.

As the first line of defense against water damage, quality gutters redirect rainwater away from your home’s foundation and protect against leaks, mold, and erosion. 

When selecting new gutters, homeowners face an important decision – copper or aluminum.

Both offer distinct advantages and downsides. This guide breaks down the key differences to help Seattle homeowners make the ideal choice for their property.

Why You Need High-Performing Gutters in Seattle’s Climate

With an average annual rainfall of 37 inches, gutters face heavy demand in Seattle. Leaky or clogged gutters can lead to thousands in repairs from wood rot, flooded basements, and structural issues. Investing in robust, professional-grade gutters tailored for our climate is a smart long-term move.

Copper Gutters – The Premium Choice for Beauty and Durability

Prized for its unparalleled durability and charming appearance, copper is the best gutter material to use especially in rainy climates. 

There are many benefits of installing copper gutter:

  • Lifetime durability – Copper gutters are renowned for their durability and long lifespan. In Seattle’s ever-changing weather, having gutters that can withstand the test of time is invaluable. With a 60-100 year lifespan, copper gutters will likely last the life of your home. The material is incredibly resilient against corrosion and decay.
  • Visually appealing Look – Copper gutters add a touch of timeless elegance to your home. Over time, they develop a beautiful patina that only enhances their visual appeal. Copper develops a unique verdant patina over time that lends homes a distinguished, antique look. 
  • Lower maintenance – Once installed properly, copper gutters require very minimal upkeep other than occasional clearing of debris. Their resistance to corrosion makes them a hassle-free option.
  • 100% recyclable – Eco-conscious homeowners appreciate that copper gutters can be fully recycled when replaced.
  • Increase Value of Homes – The timeless, high-end look of copper gutters can increase home resale value.

Disadvantages of Copper Gutters

  • Higher Cost: The initial cost of copper gutters is higher than their aluminum counterparts. However, their durability often offsets this expense.
  • Prone to Theft: In some areas, copper gutters are vulnerable to theft due to their high resale value.
  • Oxidation and Patina Development: While many homeowners love the patina that develops on copper gutters, others may not appreciate the change in appearance over time.

While copper gutters cost significantly more upfront, keep in mind copper’s unbeatable longevity. Their superior performance and aesthetic make them a worthwhile investment for many Seattle homeowners.
Learn about copper gutter installation for your home.

Affordable and Low-Maintenance Aluminum Gutters

For homeowners primarily concerned about budget, aluminum gutters provide a lighter-weight, more affordable option.

Benefits of Aluminum Gutters Include:

  • Cost-effective Solution – Aluminum gutters are a cost-effective choice for budget-conscious homeowners, offering value without sacrificing functionality. Aluminum gutters generally run about one-third the price of copper gutters. This makes them accessible for most budgets.
  • Wide range of styles – Aluminum gutters can be formed into a variety of shapes and finishes to coordinate with your home’s look.
  • Easy installation – Lightweight aluminum gutters are simpler for gutter contractors to maneuver and install. This saves on labor costs.
  • Low maintenance – Like copper gutters, aluminum requires minimal upkeep beyond periodic clearing of clogs and debris.
  • Corrosion-resistant – Modern aluminum alloys feature protective paint finishes that minimize rust and corrosion. In Seattle’s moist climate, the corrosion-resistant properties of aluminum are a significant advantage.

Disadvantages of Aluminum Gutters

  • Less Durability Compared to Copper: While aluminum gutters are durable, they may not match the extended lifespan of copper gutters.
  • Limited Aesthetic Options: Aluminum gutters may have limited aesthetic choices, which could be a concern for homeowners looking for a specific style.
  • Regular Maintenance Required: Aluminum gutters may require more maintenance due to the need for occasional repainting to prevent corrosion.

While not as durable as copper, properly installed and maintained aluminum gutters still provide 20-30 years of reliable service. The lower price point makes them an understandable choice for cost-conscious homeowners.

Key Factors in Choosing the Right Gutter Material 

When deciding between copper and aluminum rain gutters, weigh the following based on your home’s specific needs:

  • Budget – How much can you reasonably invest in new gutters? Copper gutters come at a premium price. Compare the costs of copper and aluminum gutters and consider your long-term budget.
  • Lifespan – Consider whether you are looking for a long-term investment or a more budget-friendly short-term solution. Copper gutters will outlast aluminum by decades, making them a smart long-term investment.
  • Appearance – Think about the visual style you want to achieve for your home. Do you prefer a modern look or a vintage aesthetic? Copper develops a distinctive patina. 
  • Maintenance – Both copper and aluminum gutters require minimal maintenance if installed correctly.
  • Environmental factors – Seattle’s rain and moisture levels should influence your decision. Copper stands up better to Seattle’s wet climate but aluminum works fine if properly maintained.


The choice between copper and aluminum gutters for your Seattle home is a significant decision. 

In this guide, we’ve covered the pros and cons of each material, and it’s essential to evaluate your unique needs and preferences. 

Ultimately, your decision should align with your budget, style aspirations, and the climate conditions of the Pacific Northwest.

By carefully considering these factors, Seattle homeowners can feel confident selecting the ideal gutter material for protecting their home and budget. Contact a qualified gutter installation company for help making the right choice. Invest wisely and you’ll enjoy high-functioning, worry-free gutters for decades to come.

We encourage you to carefully weigh the advantages and disadvantages presented in this article and to consult with a professional gutter installer for further guidance. Making an informed choice now will ensure that your home remains protected and visually appealing for years to come in the beautiful city of Seattle.

Need help to decide which is the right style of gutter for you? If you live in or near Seattle we’d love to help. Get quotes for copper vs. aluminum gutters for your home.

Keep your gutters performing flawlessly. Contact Gutter Seattle for expert gutter advice, gutter repair and gutter maintenance services in and near Seattle area!


Latest Articles